In Love Island USA Season 7, Episode 20 (aired June 24, 2025), the Casa Amor recoupling shocked viewers when both Nic and Olandria were left single and eliminated. Zak chose another girl, leaving Olandria vulnerable, while Clarke picked someone else, dumping Nic from the villa.
With only 30 minutes to pack and say goodbye, their departure was tearful and emotional. But right after the credits, fans were stunned to see Olandria pick up Nic in a black SUV—hinting they might not be gone after all.
Many fans were not happy. Social media was full of criticism aimed at producers for what viewers believe was a forced and fake twist.
too many people are giving production credit for bringing olandria and nic back as if they didn’t literally orchestrate the entire thing… the whole episode has production written all over it, cmon now… ???????? no one was ever going home #loveislandusa
— daniel (@ekinsupreme) June 25, 2025
pic.twitter.com/PLL4DHBpTK
Viewers voiced a range of concerns:
Forced drama: Some said the twist felt unnatural and unnecessary.
Favoritism: Others accused the show of saving Nic and Olandria only because of their popularity.
Rule-breaking: Casa Amor exits are usually final—this twist was seen as bending the rules for ratings.
Fans pointed out that Nic and Olandria don’t seem romantically interested in each other. Many believe both would rather reconnect with their original partners—Nic with Cierra, and Olandria with Taylor, who reportedly isn't even into her.
While many were frustrated, others appreciated the unexpected turn. Olandria fans, in particular, welcomed the chance for more screen time or a new love match. Some also said the twist allows Taylor and Cierra to explore new relationships without guilt.