American Idol fans were surprised and disappointed by the song choices made by contestants during a recent episode in Hawaii, describing them as "terrible" and "lackluster." Despite an impressive lineup of talent, some contestants' song selections left viewers puzzled.
During episode eight of American Idol, the top 24 contestants performed in Ko Olina, Hawaii, with Grammy award-winning singer Jelly Roll mentoring the final 12 contestants. While fans appreciated the talent on display, they were bewildered by certain contestants' song choices.
Two song choices, in particular, drew criticism: Elleigh Marie's rendition of CeeLo Green's "Forget You" and Odell Bunton Jr.'s performance of Bruno Mars' "Uptown Funk." Viewers questioned the relevance of these songs in 2024.
Fans expressed their disappointment on social media platforms like X (formerly Twitter), criticizing the song choices as lacking excitement and suitability for the competition.
Related: Hailey Mia Music Journey
Elleigh Marie, hailing from Utah, delivered an emotionally charged performance, dedicating it to her ex-boyfriend. This choice elicited mixed reactions from fans, yet many acknowledged her vocal prowess and offered unwavering support.
Odell Bunton Jr., a 28-year-old Texan contestant, shared a poignant narrative of personal development and familial solidarity before his performance. Despite the hurdles he faced, such as raising five children, he expressed profound gratitude for his transformative experience on American Idol.
