Love Island USA just dropped a serious chemistry bomb, and it has fans buzzing. On the June 13 episode, newcomer Pepe Garcia and Cierra Ortega shared a conversation that felt easy, natural, and full of mutual interest. Compared to her past chats, this one felt different — and honestly, it showed.
While Pepe was open to getting to know both Hannah and Cierra, his connection with Cierra stood out. From the start, the tone was warmer, more curious, and more personal. He complimented her smile and eyes, calling her his type, and Cierra was clearly taken aback — in a good way. She even said later that the talk “hit her like a f**king truck.”
What set this apart wasn’t just what Pepe said — it was how Cierra responded. This didn’t feel like surface-level flirting. She looked genuinely intrigued and thoughtful afterward. For the first time, it felt like someone truly saw her beyond the surface, and that energy felt sincere.
Meanwhile, Nic’s reaction said it all. He didn’t just seem worried — he looked like someone who realized he could lose his connection with Cierra. Their interactions have always felt light and a bit shallow. With Pepe, Cierra looked more present and emotionally open, which speaks volumes.