When Olandria and Nic returned to the Love Island USA villa as a couple after the dramatic Casa Amor twist, fans were left shocked — and emotions inside the villa ran high.
Image source: IG/loveislandusa
After their elimination during the Casa Amor phase for not recoupling with anyone new, Olandria and Nic were offered a surprising second chance. They went on a date and had to choose: return to the villa as a couple or walk away single. Choosing love, they re-entered the villa — together.
Image source: IG/loveislandusa
During Olandria’s time at Casa Amor, her original match, Taylor, grew close to Clarke, one of the new bombshells. Their bond intensified, and Taylor even kissed Clarke — clearly signaling a shift in his romantic focus.
Image source: IG/loveislandusa
Even after returning with Nic, Olandria confessed she had always been “Team Taylor.” She admitted her strong feelings but made it clear she wouldn’t fight for someone who easily moved on.
Upon her return, Taylor didn’t immediately speak to Olandria. In fact, he seemed more excited to see Nic than her. It wasn’t until fellow islander Ace encouraged him that Taylor finally talked to Olandria.
Image source: IG/loveislandusa
When they talked, Taylor said he still wanted to get to know Clarke. Olandria was hurt but said she understood. She admitted it was hard not to compare her past with Taylor to his new connection with Clarke.
Still, she left the door slightly open:
“The ball is in his court.”
Read more: Jeremiah Brown Reveals Truth Behind Love Island Exit
Image source: IG/loveislandusa
Taylor told both Clarke and Olandria that he wanted to be honest while he sorted out his feelings. Olandria, on the other hand, was stuck — unsure whether to give her new connection with Nic a real chance or keep hoping Taylor would come back to her.