In Love Island USA Season 7, Episode 21, Taylor found himself in hot water with fans after the Casa Amor twist. Viewers were frustrated when Taylor only spoke to Olandria after being encouraged by fellow Islander Ace. For many fans, this raised questions about whether Taylor was ever truly serious about Olandria or just going through the motions.
Image source: IG/loveislandusa
Twitter and Instagram lit up with criticism. Fans couldn’t believe that a 24-year-old man needed another contestant's permission to engage with someone he was supposedly romantically interested in. Many labeled Taylor a “loser,” expressing frustration over his inability to act independently.
Image source: IG/loveislandusa
Read more: Nic and Olandria Reunite and Return on Love Island USA
What made matters worse for fans was Taylor’s confession that he was not physically attracted to Olandria. His emotional and physical detachment became obvious, especially compared to Olandria’s efforts to connect.
Image source: IG/loveislandusa
Olandria has also voiced her concerns, mentioning the lack of physical chemistry and how their actions didn’t match their words. She’s been open about wanting more affection and clarity, but Taylor's hesitancy has only deepened the awkwardness in their connection.
Is this cowboy looking for greener pastures? ???? #LoveIslandUSA pic.twitter.com/pk4MrigDkE
— Love Island USA (@loveislandusa) June 27, 2025
It wasn’t just the conversation that required a push—Ace also had to motivate Taylor to plan dates with Olandria. Viewers took this as another sign that Taylor isn’t truly invested and is overly reliant on Ace to manage his romantic interactions.
The overwhelming fan sentiment? “Olandria deserves better.” Many have demanded that Taylor leave the villa to make room for someone who genuinely wants to pursue Olandria without external influence. Viewers are rooting for Olandria to find a partner who values her without needing a wingman to guide them.
Image source: IG/loveislandusa